A class-action lawsuit challenging the legality of an $80 annual parks and recreation fee in Horseshoe Bend is scheduled to go to trial the week of December 10. A pretrial hearing has been set for Tuesday to address several pending motions.
Kenneth Holland and Michelle Graetz, Horseshoe Bend property owners, filed the lawsuit on May 4 on behalf of themselves and other similarly situated taxpayers. The lawsuit contends that the $80-per-lot fee, introduced in 2025 under a city ordinance, constitutes an unconstitutional tax.
The city of Horseshoe Bend has reportedly pursued cases against property owners for nonpayment of the fee. According to the plaintiffs, approximately 70 property owners, including themselves, were served court summonses to appear on May 5 regarding nonpayment. Records indicate the city collected $531,000 in total from the fee in 2025, which was allocated to the parks and recreation department.
During a pretrial conference call on October 29, Circuit Judge Holly Meyer ruled that the city, represented by defendants including Mayor Duane DeClair in his official capacity, had failed to meet court-ordered discovery deadlines. Both parties, the city and the plaintiffs, later filed motions requesting a continuance. Judge Meyer is expected to address those motions at Tuesday’s hearing.
The plaintiffs' motion for summary judgment will also be considered during the Tuesday hearing. If granted, the summary judgment could resolve the case before it reaches trial.
This lawsuit highlights ongoing questions about revenue measures at the local level and whether specific fees meet constitutional guidelines. Horseshoe Bend residents and other observers are closely monitoring the outcome, which could have broader implications for municipal fee structures in Arkansas.
