Arkansas Supreme Court Justice Cody Hiland appeared before the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee on Wednesday, addressing lawmakers as they consider his nomination to the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. His testimony covered questions about the 2020 presidential election, ongoing issues with Arkansas bar exam tampering, and his judicial philosophy.
Hiland, a former federal prosecutor and chairman of the Arkansas Republican Party, was nominated last week by President Donald Trump after the withdrawal of U.S. District Court Judge Lee Rudofsky’s nomination. During his opening remarks, Hiland emphasized his goal of honoring the responsibilities of a federal appeals judge.
"My goal is for people to say Judge Hiland brought honor to the title of 8th Circuit judge," he said.
Sen. Richard Blumenthal, a Democrat from Connecticut, pressed Hiland on his views about the 2020 presidential election, asking who won the popular vote. Hiland acknowledged that Joe Biden was certified the winner of the Electoral College but declined to answer specifically about the popular vote.
"Senator, the popular vote is not what’s important," Hiland said. "Respectfully, it’s the Electoral College, and Joe Biden received those votes."
When pressed further, Hiland stated, "I think it’s going down a political track on an issue that happened six years ago, and I don’t want to come close to a potential ethical violation."
The committee also raised questions about an investigation into bar exam tampering at the Arkansas Supreme Court’s Office of Professional Programs. Federal authorities recently arrested the office’s former director on charges that bar exam scores were altered between 2020 and 2025. Responding to inquiries from Sen. Dick Durbin, Hiland said he became aware of the investigation in May and has had no involvement in the alleged misconduct.
"We’re trying to get our hands around exactly what the universe of the problem is," he said.
Additionally, Hiland was asked to clarify remarks he made during a speech to law students in August. At the time, he described himself as "belligerent" in rejecting a federal district court nomination to pursue an appellate judgeship instead. On Wednesday, he revised his statement, saying he had misspoken in the casual setting.
"This was a 10-minute, extemporaneous speech to first-year law students," Hiland explained. "When we speak extemporaneously, sometimes we use words we shouldn’t. The proper word was probably ‘resolute.’"
Arkansas’ Republican senators, Tom Cotton and John Boozman, both praised Hiland in their remarks to the committee. Cotton cited Hiland’s experience as a lawyer and judge and his commitment to the rule of law. Boozman noted Hiland’s qualifications, including his temperament and extensive legal background.
"Cody Hiland has all the qualities we want in a federal judge," Boozman said.
However, Durbin, a Democrat, voiced "deep concerns" about Hiland’s political background and referenced a controversial 2022 Arkansas Supreme Court decision that allowed the state legislature to amend voter-approved constitutional amendments.
Durbin also criticized Senate Republicans for expediting judicial confirmations before losing their majority in January, saying, "Just eight days after the committee’s last nominations hearing, we’re back again because Senate Republicans are determined to confirm as many nominees as possible before control of the Senate shifts."
The 8th Circuit covers a seven-state region, including Arkansas, Iowa, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, North Dakota, and South Dakota. Hiland’s nomination awaits further action by the Senate Judiciary Committee.
